Hickok45 on You Tube compares the two. He favors the gen 4 model over the gen 3. But that is his preference. There are some aftermarket parts for the gen 4 but not many.

Depending on what mods you want to do with the gun, the most flexibility at this point is the gen 3. The gen 4 will eventually get to this point.

If you are a GSSF member and have a local gun shop that will honor the GSSF gun program, then buy through them. If you don't have anyone around, check out Ed's Public Safety, they will treat you right. If you’re not a member, consider it. You may check some of your local guns shops and see what they would do on prices. I have one here that will match a cheaper price, provided you can document the price and its accuracy.

Holsters are like opinions....everyone has one and it is the right one. There are a lot variances with this; carry all day, your dress, job, body, are just to name a few. It'll be more trial and error than a science.

I haven't shot the gen 4 yet so I don't have factual info on how it shoots. But check out Hickok45s video.

Good Luck and have fun!


:wavey:


red

 

I have a gen 4 G23. I'm pretty happy with the way it shoots. I have to be honest though, I've shot the gen3 and gen 4 G23 and didn't notice much difference in the way they shoot. I love the way Glock shoots period.

I do like having the interchangeable backstraps. Gives me the flexibility to find the right grip feel of the gun. I also like the heavier duty spring.

Just an opinion, believe me, I am FAR from an expert. Good luck with the purchase!

I am actually thinking of joining the GSSF as well for the gun purchase program. Sounds like a sweet deal!

Safe Shooting!

 

Hickok45 on You Tube compares the two.

Do you have a link to this video? I'd like to watch. Thanks!

Safe shooting!

 

[/COLOR]

You must not know where to shop. :whistling:

 

The only two common aftermarket "upgrades" that aren't currently available for the Gen 4 G23 are a butt plug and ambidextrous mags. Sights, springs, connectors, barrels, etc., are all available and/or already work with the Gen 4, so don't let that stop you.

 

I have just had to make the same decision. I ordered the G23 Gen 4, but I won't be taking possession of it for a couple months. I will keep the forum posted.

 

Do you have a link to this video? I'd like to watch. Thanks!

Safe shooting!

Actually it's a Gen2 vs. Gen 4 comparison
http://www.youtube.com/user/hickok45#p/u/19/kXS3c110Te4

The main differences between the Gen 3 & Gen 4 is the Gen4 offers different size backstrap options, and a completely redesigned recoil spring assembly. If the grip flexibility offered by the Gen4 is important to you, go with that one, otherwise either one should be just fine.

 

If you plan on using Crimson Trace laser grips, I don't believe they are (yet) available for the Gen 4. it would be difficult, given the adjustable backstraps.
I've got the CT's on my OD gen 3 and really like them.
John

 

Where should I buy and which pistols should I go with? Also what mods and iwb holster should I grab?

IMO join GSSF & buy from Ed's, Gen 4, no mods, & Comp-Tac MTAC.

 

[/COLOR]

You must not know where to shop. :whistling:

That was helpful...

 

If you plan on using Crimson Trace laser grips, I don't believe they are (yet) available for the Gen 4. it would be difficult, given the adjustable backstraps.
I've got the CT's on my OD gen 3 and really like them.
John

Im guessing that you would be resigned to use the crimson trace "laserguard" product. I am doubtful that CT will bother trying to desin laser "grips" for an interchangeable grip gun..

Again, though, the crimson trace "laserguard" product would make more sense.

 

Actually it's a Gen2 vs. Gen 4 comparison
http://www.youtube.com/user/hickok45#p/u/19/kXS3c110Te4

The main differences between the Gen 3 & Gen 4 is the Gen4 offers different size backstrap options, and a completely redesigned recoil spring assembly. If the grip flexibility offered by the Gen4 is important to you, go with that one, otherwise either one should be just fine.

Thanks for the correction, my bad, he had a gen 3 g19 instead of the gen3 g23. It was a gen2...thanks for posting the link. Just was able to get back on the 'net.


:wavey:


red

 

[/COLOR]

You must not know where to shop. :whistling:

There are some pins, a trigger assembly from Glockmeister and have heard of a couple of small things from other online suppliers (haven't seen them to know exactly what they are)....but like was stated earlier, there aren't many.

Does that help, JBP55?


:wavey:


red

 

I think whatever would feel best to you. I hear the grips on gen 4s are less exaggerated as compared to gen 3's. I'd like to get a hold of a gen4 to do a comparison.

 

From all accounts the Gen4 .40s are pretty good.

 

For .40/.357, I'd go with a gen 4 OR gen 3 with a wolff uncaptured guiderod and 20# recoil spring. Gen2/3 .40/.357s are undersprung particularly if you plan to use a weapon light.

For 9mm, gen3 for sure.

 

For .40/.357, I'd go with a gen 4 OR gen 3 with a wolff uncaptured guiderod and 20# recoil spring. Gen2/3 .40/.357s are undersprung particularly if you plan to use a weapon light.

For 9mm, gen3 for sure.

What is the poundage on the gen 4 springs?

Why 9mm in gen3 4sure?

 

If you want a smooth glossy slide, get a Gen3. I've got a Gen 4 22 and just got a Gen 4 23. The 22 is one of the early ones that don't have the recessed rim for the spring in the front of the slide. Anyway, the 22 has a nice glossy slide and the 23 has a flat grey looking slide that already shows signs of use from nicks and dings from carry. The barrels on both are flat grey. People who claim the Gen 4's recoil less or whatever are FOS. Really the only benefit is the recoil assemblies should last at least twice as long before replacement because the springs are working half as hard. A 20# recoil assembly is going to feel the same if all other things are the same whether it's accomplished with one or two springs.

 

What is the poundage on the gen 4 springs?

Why 9mm in gen3 4sure?

I don't know the rate of a gen 4 recoil spring but it's widely acknowledged that it: a) is heavier than gen 3 b) solved the problems that some .40cal gen 3's had with weapons lights (via lowering excessive slide velocity). The latter being a major complaint of major L/E organizations.

Without trying to start a pissing contest, many believe (I'm one of them) that the gen 3 recoil spring rate is correct for a 9mm but too light for a .40. Many also believe (I'm one of them) that the gen 4 recoil spring rate is correct for a .40 but too heavy for a 9mm.

 

If you want a smooth glossy slide, get a Gen3. I've got a Gen 4 22 and just got a Gen 4 23. The 22 is one of the early ones that don't have the recessed rim for the spring in the front of the slide. Anyway, the 22 has a nice glossy slide and the 23 has a flat grey looking slide that already shows signs of use from nicks and dings from carry. The barrels on both are flat grey. People who claim the Gen 4's recoil less or whatever are FOS. Really the only benefit is the recoil assemblies should last at least twice as long before replacement because the springs are working half as hard. A 20# recoil assembly is going to feel the same if all other things are the same whether it's accomplished with one or two springs.

My Gen 3 22 and 23 feel about the same as the Gen 4 22 I purchased. I have stainless steel rods and springs in my gen 3's so they shoot pretty soft!!