Glock Talk banner
  • Notice image

    Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about Glock pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and more!

41 - 60 of 62 Posts
You have no love for Rossi?

Charter Arms? Rock Island? Tisas?

It's a big family where stepchildren, cousins, and creepy uncles abound.
I can only speak for Kimber, Hi-Point, and Taurus. I have no personal knowledge of the cousins or creepy uncles. 😀
 
  • Like
Reactions: 40/45
I bought the 357 k6 maybe a year or so ago and it has been flawless. July 10th I bought the k6xs 38. Brought it home and went out in the backyard and shot 6 rounds through it, then it broke. Sent it back to Kimber and got it back today. They had replaced the firing pin. Loaded six rounds and shot it, then it broke again. I'm sending it back tomorrow along with the receipt for $575.00 I paid for it and asking for a refund. Don't know whats going on with it but I would never be able to trust it. View attachment 1314061
I ordered one and rejected it, sent it back for refund.

When you press the cylinder release the cylinder has vertical play on the rear end, and it was out of time.

They have some qc to sort out. Trigger felt nice and I liked it a lot, hope they sort out the issues!
 
I was never a fan of their revolvers.

I own a older Pro Carry ll that kimber refurbished in 2006 for only $100. It's been very reliable since then. The only 1911 I own.

I've had them service it twice for complete gone through. Never had a issue with their CS.
 
Was it the firing pin issue each time you sent it back or something else? This is not good news if Kimber is having overall QC issues because the Kimber K6 is the most compact six shot 357 with just enough weight to absorb the Recoil. The Ruger SP 101 is a similar size and weight but only holds 5 rounds.

But the earlier Ruger Speed Six and Service Six were only little larger than the SP101 and held six shots. And I considr the S&W airweight J frame 357's to be impractical in every way except in theory.
My wife owns a Ruger SP–101 with a 3 inch barrel in 357 Magnum. It's a, 'bear of a gun'. You can shoot full house loads through it all day long until it's, literally, too hot to handle without wearing gloves; and it just keeps on going, and going, and going!

It's got a very smooth trigger job by Chuck Lutz (a local gunsmith who used to maintain revolvers for the Philadelphia Police Department), a Hogue soft rubber Monogrip, and a (very useful) hammer spur.

On my less paranoid days, when I like to imagine that we still live in a better world where revolvers were 'enough gun', I'll take it away from her and carry it myself.

It's just an ultra-reliable, heavyweight, not-so-little, little gun. The 5 shot capacity doesn't bother me; I always carry it with 2 speed loaders, anyway; and, at close range (which is what it's designed for) I'm sure it'll keep me out of trouble.

Image


Image


Image
 
  • Like
Reactions: mjh42
Discussion starter · #47 ·
My wife owns a Ruger SP–101 with a 3 inch barrel in 357 Magnum. It's a, 'bear of a gun'. You can shoot full house loads through it all day long until it's, literally, too hot to handle without wearing gloves; and it just keeps on going, and going, and going!

It's got a very smooth trigger job by Chuck Lutz (a local gunsmith who used to maintain revolvers for the Philadelphia Police Department), a Hogue soft rubber Monogrip, and a (very useful) hammer spur.

On my less paranoid days, when I like to imagine that we still live in a better world where revolvers were 'enough gun', I'll take it away from her and carry it myself.

It's just an ultra-reliable, heavyweight, not-so-little, little gun. The 5 shot capacity doesn't bother me; I always carry it with 2 speed loaders, anyway; and, at close range (which is what it's designed for) I'm sure it'll keep me out of trouble.

View attachment 1315090

View attachment 1315094

View attachment 1315095
The sp101's are fine revolvers
Image
Image
 
My wife owns a Ruger SP–101 with a 3 inch barrel in 357 Magnum. It's a, 'bear of a gun'. You can shoot full house loads through it all day long until it's, literally, too hot to handle without wearing gloves; and it just keeps on going, and going, and going!

It's got a very smooth trigger job by Chuck Lutz (a local gunsmith who used to maintain revolvers for the Philadelphia Police Department), a Hogue soft rubber Monogrip, and a (very useful) hammer spur.

On my less paranoid days, when I like to imagine that we still live in a better world where revolvers were 'enough gun', I'll take it away from her and carry it myself.

It's just an ultra-reliable, heavyweight, not-so-little, little gun. The 5 shot capacity doesn't bother me; I always carry it with 2 speed loaders, anyway; and, at close range (which is what it's designed for) I'm sure it'll keep me out of trouble.

View attachment 1315090

View attachment 1315094

View attachment 1315095
👍👍👍. With a SP-101 if I run out of ammo I can still beat them to death with it without any damage. It’s like Thor’s own hammer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G21.4Me and Bosch
Sure there is. Fails significantly three times in a row, each time just six rounds? Single out Kimber. They claim to be high end, but clearly aren’t.

Twice. It broke twice.

I'd say on average I've returned 40% of the firearms I've bought after one range trip to have something fixed. The only outlier are the Glocks. Oh and neither my Kimber 1911 or my K6DASA but I only own those two examples. I'm talking about brands I have several examples of.

Ruger, Springfield, CZ, FN, S&W.


Absolutely no manufacturer has anywhere near a perfect record across the board. Especially not new products.
 
I've long been a S&W and Ruger revolver guy and most recently Colt.
All good...
The most recent though is an all stainless Taurus 856 - and I must admit it's been excellent.
Having the extra round in the cylinder (6-shot) is also good...
I like Taurus revolvers. Own two.
Image

Image
 
Sure there is. Fails significantly three times in a row, each time just six rounds? Single out Kimber. They claim to be high end, but clearly aren’t.
They are near the same price as S&W revolvers. S&W has been basically making the same exact revolvers for several decades. Kimber been doing it only for a few years. They both have similar QA issues, but Kimber is bashed and held to a higher standard than both S&W and Colt/CZ. Colt/CZ also are hot or miss. That's my only point. There's a clear bias, and for the most part, Kimber revolvers have better quality, fit and finish, and QC than both S&W standard and Performance Center revolvers.
 
Twice. It broke twice.

I'd say on average I've returned 40% of the firearms I've bought after one range trip to have something fixed. The only outlier are the Glocks. Oh and neither my Kimber 1911 or my K6DASA but I only own those two examples. I'm talking about brands I have several examples of.

Ruger, Springfield, CZ, FN, S&W.


Absolutely no manufacturer has anywhere near a perfect record across the board. Especially not new products.
Thank You!!!
 
Shortly after they came out, I wanted a small compact revolver.
I went to my local shop and tried the Colt Cobra. Was surprised how much stacking the trigger had and the pull got VERY difficult at the end of the travel. (Note: I picked up a King Cobra a number of months ago and it had a sweet trigger - none of the issues that the Cobra had.)
So, I checked out the Kimber K6s. A very nice revolver (the DAO version) and have to say the trigger pull was nice and the quality was excellent.
I'm more of a DA/SA revolver guy (never had a DAO revolver before), and even though I could 'stage' the trigger on that Kimber, I just preferred to have an external hammer.
So, I sold that Kimber (NOT due to any problems) and that's why I got my first Colt - the current King Cobra and have never looked back.
Just swapped out that gold/brass bead front sight for a red fiber optic (aging eyes that I have) and that King Cobra has been excellent.

So - apparently others in this thread have had Kimber quality issues, but I have to say that in the year that I had mine - I did not have any issues whatsoever...
 
The K6XS is a cheap corner cutting revolver that's new to market thus will have teething issues. It's also budget priced, unlike other Kimber offerings. I've owned a Kimber KS6 DASA for 3+ years now without a single issue, and the quality is superior to Ruger and S&W IMHO.

Note that, like me, the OP purchased the stainless steel K6S too, and had no issues. If you go to the smith-wessonforum.com, Thehighroad.org, and even thus forum, and do a search for the new S&W Ultimate Carry revolvers, you'll see worse issues than with Kimber, and S&W has been basically been making the same revolver s for several decades longer than the Kimber has.
I wonder if part of that was caused by the move from Massachusetts to Tennessee. I'm beginning to think no one can make a reliable revolver anymore.
 
41 - 60 of 62 Posts