Glock Talk banner
  • Notice image

    Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about Glock pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and more!

1 - 20 of 26 Posts
I have Dewey cleaning rods for both rifle and pistol. But if I needed to start over I would get the carbon fiber rods.
 
Forgot to add make sure whatever you get itÂ’s a one piece rod not including the screw on tips and do not get the coated rods or any with a soft metal like aluminum or brass.
 
Another vote for Dewey.

wp
 
you'll notice that a lot of replies have the words "carbon fiber" in them....

go to wally world and get the cheapest, smallest dia. carbon arrow, about 4-5 bucks.

then go to the gun cleaning supplies and find which make brush/bore mop/jag threads into the end for the point.

then go to the hardware section and find a piece of heat shrink tube that will slip over the shaft and shrink to a tight fit when heated.

cut the arrow shaft to cleaning length plus handle length with a high speed cut off wheel (think dremel with a wiz wheel), add the heat shrink tube for the handle with 1/4" hanging off the end you just cut so when heat shrinked it covers the end, and ta-da you have a custom length cleaning rod with enough arrow shaft left over to make a second one.

yes, yes, the CRB is strong in this one.....(said in a "yoda" like voice)

sig357fan
 
preferably about 8 inches long ?
Best/joe
Pretty much anybody. It's a rod. As long as the various cleaning tips from various manufacturers screw on (as opposed to the ones with their own thread size) it's fine.
 
you'll notice that a lot of replies have the words "carbon fiber" in them....

go to wally world and get the cheapest, smallest dia. carbon arrow, about 4-5 bucks.

then go to the gun cleaning supplies and find which make brush/bore mop/jag threads into the end for the point.

then go to the hardware section and find a piece of heat shrink tube that will slip over the shaft and shrink to a tight fit when heated.

cut the arrow shaft to cleaning length plus handle length with a high speed cut off wheel (think dremel with a wiz wheel), add the heat shrink tube for the handle with 1/4" hanging off the end you just cut so when heat shrinked it covers the end, and ta-da you have a custom length cleaning rod with enough arrow shaft left over to make a second one.

yes, yes, the CRB is strong in this one.....(said in a "yoda" like voice)

sig357fan
So $10-12 for the cheapest carbon fiber arrow, some heat shrink tubing, cleaning tips...

For less than that, I can buy a whole pistol cleaning kit, complete with rod, tips, toothbrush, patches, etc.

I can buy carbon fiber, aluminum, brass, steel (coated or not) because it's a pistol rod and unless I'm going to rub it against the inside and crown of the bore, it makes no difference what it's made of (except aluminum tends to bend and break easiest).

OP - $8.99 Winchester kit:
Image


Parts store in the handle. There are several other brands of similar pistol cleaning kits.
 
I see the need for the better rods with Long Rifle Barrels, but pistol is not the same. Even a cheap aluminum rod will never touch the rifling. It's simply can't flex enough to do that. Nothing wrong with a nice rod. The feel of quality may be worth it to you. But it won't make any difference in a short barrel.
 
I have the 12" Tipton. Honestly, it's a tad too big for pistols. Kind of a pain in the ass. While I too was taken with the idea of "carbon fiber" when I got it, if I were to do over, I'd just get the Dewey.
 
I see the need for the better rods with Long Rifle Barrels, but pistol is not the same. Even a cheap aluminum rod will never touch the rifling. It's simply can't flex enough to do that. Nothing wrong with a nice rod. The feel of quality may be worth it to you. But it won't make any difference in a short barrel.
The reason IÂ’m suggesting the Tipton or carbon fiber rods. Some people also have, shoot and clean revolvers. Where there is a good chance of rubbing the crown of the bore. Two piece rods have a tendency to unscrew, bend, and cheap handles.
 
Discussion starter · #18 ·
I have the 12" Tipton. Honestly, it's a tad too big for pistols. Kind of a pain in the ass. While I too was taken with the idea of "carbon fiber" when I got it, if I were to do over, I'd just get the Dewey.
This one is 8 inches, and the one I ordered, because it was 8 inches will report back after I run it through a Glock or 2.......Best/joe

[ame="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001NOVF92/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1"]Amazon.com : Gunslick Handgun Carbon Fiber Cleaning Rod : Gun Cleaning Kits : Sports & Outdoors@@AMEPARAM@@http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/21VNb12VgZL.@@AMEPARAM@@21VNb12VgZL[/ame]
 
Every one of the carbon fiber rods I have purchased has failed. The rods work fine for pushing a patch through the barrel, just don't try to pull because the tip will come off.

Coated rods have the disadvantage that grit may embed in the surface. OTOH, when clean, they won't damage the barrel or the crown.

Metal rods won't be used in my rifles. Pistols, sure, but never in rifles.

Any rod you can come up with will work fine in a pistol. I use one of the cheap Outers kits.

Richard
 
1 - 20 of 26 Posts