Glock Talk banner
  • Notice image

    Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about Glock pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and more!

Stranded, Lost, and Just One Knife to rely upon

9.9K views 58 replies 37 participants last post by  screaminbeagle  
#1 ·
Budget before this happened $100.00.

What would you buy?
 
#2 ·
hmmmm.... the budget guidelines shot down the reply i was contemplating based on the title. which would've been my ESEE 5. it's always with me as is a compass, lighter, and flashlight. between those four, i should be aight :D
 
#5 · (Edited)
Ka-bar.

And I do keep a fire starter block on my sheath. A compass might be nice, but I live in the N.W. so finding direction isn't too hard based on local plants.
 
#7 ·
Think the $100.00 is a reasonable budget!

oh, i'm not saying it's not reasonable. i'm just saying it shot down the suggestion i had in mind, when i read the title. it's also the very knfie i DO carry just in case i find myself in the predicament you described in the title :cool:

i guess for under a hunj, i'd look at the Ontario Ranger RD series.
 
#12 ·
Bear Grylls Gerber:

Image
It has:


  • Molded rubber grip and knurled striking surface butt cap
  • Saw ground back blade
  • Integrated fire starter with integrated diamond sharpener
  • Key ground-air communication patch
  • Emergency micro lanyard whistle
and a little survival guide built into the sheath as well.

You could almost buy 2 for your budget. They run around $60.
 
#14 ·
Bear Grylls Gerber:

Image
It has:


  • Molded rubber grip and knurled striking surface butt cap
  • Saw ground back blade
  • Integrated fire starter with integrated diamond sharpener
  • Key ground-air communication patch
  • Emergency micro lanyard whistle
and a little survival guide built into the sheath as well.

You could almost buy 2 for your budget. They run around $60.
That too looks like it would work.
 
#15 · (Edited)
Bear Grylls Gerber:

Image
It has:


  • Molded rubber grip and knurled striking surface butt cap
  • Saw ground back blade
  • Integrated fire starter with integrated diamond sharpener
  • Key ground-air communication patch
  • Emergency micro lanyard whistle
and a little survival guide built into the sheath as well.

You could almost buy 2 for your budget. They run around $60.
This looks great... I'd pay $10 more for it if it wasn't associated with Grylls!


I'd second the Pilot's Knife and a swiss army knife.
 
#19 ·
Bear Grylls Gerber:

Image
It has:


  • Molded rubber grip and knurled striking surface butt cap
  • Saw ground back blade
  • Integrated fire starter with integrated diamond sharpener
  • Key ground-air communication patch
  • Emergency micro lanyard whistle
and a little survival guide built into the sheath as well.

You could almost buy 2 for your budget. They run around $60.
The Bear Grylls knife seems to be a gimmick. It has not been well received over at Bladeforums.

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=790424

My first choice would be something from Esee, but since they are over the $100 price point I'd look probably look at something from Kabar. I might even go for the Kabar Kukri and sacrifice smaller detailed cutting in order to gain stronger chopping power.
 
#20 ·
I am under the $100 limit, but have more than one blade.
Gerber Multi-Plier 600 Fisherman + socket bit set
Gerber 22-49470 Gator Combo Axe

I have taken the above to the BWCA. The only additional item I added was a large swiss army knife. I did this so I would have the ability to use one tool for turning screws and one for holding the nut. And I wanted a magnifying glass and tweezers. I have considered trading off the Swiss army knife, but would not trade the Gerber tool or hatchet with knife.
I have considered
 
#21 ·
For one knife, I don't have an answer. Scrapper6 was $100, but not any more. My Spydeco CTR-XPS is more than $100.

Kershaw Outcast Bush Knife in D2?
 
#22 ·
The idea of a multi-tool is a good idea.
I would not however pic a Gerber tool.

My new Gerber 600 that I bought to replace my old one, can't even touch the old worn 600 in quality. Having said that I would always pick a Leatherman over a Gerber.
Damn his politics, his tools are superior.
 
#26 · (Edited)
The idea of a multi-tool is a good idea.
I would not however pic a Gerber tool.

My new Gerber 600 that I bought to replace my old one, can't even touch the old worn 600 in quality. Having said that I would always pick a Leatherman over a Gerber.
Damn his politics, his tools are superior.
Funny how things change.

I had an older Leatherman. I killed it.
I have bought several Gerbers and like them. (But not recently.)


As far as his politics, if you really feel his tool are greatly superior, I don't blame you. But most of the reviews I have seen are not based on overall quality. They are based on feel and one reviewer thought that the knife deployment was too slow. None of which I consider important.


Now if leather man was making his tool out of D2 or Carpenter steel..... and Gerber was continuing to use their ok unknown steel, then I would go with leatherman.