First throwing ax bullseye.
I've been a fan of Band of Brothers for a long time. Own the box set and have watched it many times. When 'The Pacific' came out it was basically billed as being just like BoB except it was set in the Pacific campaign. Since then I've heard many times that The Pacific wasn't as good as BoB. Several months ago I was able to pick up the box set of The Pacific at Goodwill for $5. Today I finally started watching it. IMNSHO BoB is a way more compelling story. At least told better. By the end of the first episode of BoB you know who most of the characters are. I'm two episodes into The Pacific and I can only reliably identify two characters and I don't know who anyone else is or why I should be interested in them. Not saying it's not good. Just BoB is better. I'll finish watching it. But at this point I don't think I'll look forward to watching it again as I do with BoB.