I recreated the malfunction at home with an empty case. At the range, ended up having to pry it out with the help of a friend and his pliers while I held the slide back (weapon wouldn't allow me much slide movement). Case mouth all chewed up. Gun was my Springfield Loaded Park 5". Ammo was S&B 230gr through a Wilson 47D. My first real malfunction with this weapon (not counting the Wolf cartridge I neglected to chamber in a bowling pin match). I'm just wondering if it's extractor, magazine, etc? Never had an empty case try to reload itself back into the magazine.