Privacy guaranteed - Your email is not shared with anyone.
Separate names with a comma.
If you consider yourself a beginner or an avid shooter, the Glock Talk community is your place to discuss self defense, concealed carry, reloading, target shooting, and all things Glock.
Discussion in 'The Cutting Edge' started by gwalchmai, Mar 24, 2010.
Which is better and why, and on what stones?
I assume you mean sharpening stones, for knives? I prefer water, easy cleanup and doesn't leave a mess like oil does. Stones, I have no idea, I have three or four that I picked up at garage sales for a dime a piece. I have no idea what their lineage is nor who made them, but they sharpen my knives just fine.
Sorry, yes, I meant which do you prefer for lubricating and cleaning your stones. Obviously water stones would use water, but do any other stones work better with oil or water?
Another q - can you switch to water after using oil on a stone?
I use DMT diamond whet stones w/ water as they suggest. An 8000 grit diamond stone will put a pretty keen edge on a knife.
I have always used an oil stone, until I bought a DMT diamond stone.
It says to use water, which I have. I just don't think it does that great of a job.
I've used diamond "stones" for a long time. They're great for building an edge, but I don't think they hone as well as rocks do.
The 8000 grit does, the only thing I know of that might do better is a 10000 grit japanese water stone.
I have a hals pro edge three stone custom kit, it has a hard ark, a surgical translucent, and a hard black, I use oil on it, and I have a lanskys, I use oil in it too, I love both of these sharpeners and use them both frequently. They both do a great job.
I think the finest diamond I have is 600. Yes, I bet an 8000 would be great!
Water. Once you go to oil, you can't go back to water. So stay with water.
I started out with oil (back in the '70s) and moved on to water.