Opinion on a cheap old revolver?

Discussion in 'General Firearms Forum' started by CompleteNerd, Sep 25, 2012.

  1. Hey folks,

    Well I suppose I was asking for this. The wife is pregnant and I'm sitting here feeling the pressure to get my CHL and a gun. I was trying to incrementally get my wife accustomed to the idea of a firearm but my timetables, of course, had to be moved up.

    But with timetables moving up I'm also having to move forward without the amount of money I would like to spend.

    I have been taking a very serious look at the police trade-in model 64's on J&G. $279, .38 special, basically some old beater guns ready to be abused.

    So here's my question: what are your thoughts on the S&W model 64? Specifically the NY-1 version. Is this worth the money? Concealability seems like a bit of an issue here, I would love to hear your thoughts on this as well.

    And to get to the Glock portion I mentioned...I haven't gotten a chance to look around too much lately, but are there any Glock options that aren't going to run me over about three hundred and fifty dollars?

    Admittedly, I have pretty much come to terms with not having a Glock just yet and having to dream. Cost is a HUGE factor right now with an unexpected pregnancy, but as the future father and husband I need to figure out a way to make sure my little family is protected at all times.

    Thanks guys & gals, and hopefully you all have a great day.

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. Loading...

    Similar Threads Forum Date
    Opinion on best (accurate) cheap 9mm ammo General Glocking Jan 15, 2015
    AR's? what is your opinion on cheap/decent/top shelf??? Black Rifle Forum May 26, 2010
    opinions on the 40sw as a self defense caliber and the glock 22 and 23 as a 40 caliber platform. Caliber Corner Saturday at 5:57 PM
    Massad what your opinion of the 40 caliber compared to the 9 mm and 45 acp? GATE Self-Defense Forum Saturday at 5:46 PM
    Your opinion of Green Slime, please. The Okie Corral Friday at 2:08 PM

  3. fnfalman

    fnfalman Chicks Dig It

    It's just a fixed sight stainless steel K-frame. Nothing special, yet highly serviceable. If the gun isn't beaten to hell and fallen apart, then that price is damn good. It's not a pocket gun but with a decent belt holster, I don't see what the problem is for concealment.

  4. janice6

    Platinum Member

    Good gun. simple and functional. Price is good too. I would buy it right now (for myself) at that price.
  5. MrMurphy

    MrMurphy *********
    Moderator Moderator Millennium Member Lifetime Member


    I started out shooting handguns on a Model 10 HB, very similar (4" blued K frame) and if the action isn't beaten to hell they're good shooting and soft recoiling.

    A 4" K isn't the ideal CCW piece but it's certainly hideable especially in winter.

    If you have someone around who knows wheelguns, have them eyeball it, check the timing and forcing cone if possible. If it's an NYPD gun, it could be totally screwed or nearly unfired.....never know.
  6. I agree with all of the above and will add two things

    IMO the Smith "K" frames like the 64 are one of the finest all around revolvers in existence.

    If you are considering CCW with it, or any handgun, please do yourself a big favor. I know cash is tight but really, get yourself the best holster you can. No $15 specials. The holster makes or breaks the effectiveness and comfort of concealed carry. IMO the best holster for CCW of a 4" K is the Milt Sparks Summer special inside the waistband. I admit to not having tried all the holsters out there, but that one is kind of my gold standard. Most folks don't think of a 4" in an IWB holster but it is a very overlooked option that can work well when a bulky cover garment is out of the question.

    There are a number of good outside the waistband rigs. I am partial to the "pancake style for concealment.

    Make sure you have a belt that is up to it too.

    I would raher carry my 4" K frame .38 (mine is a model 10) in a quality holster than one of my best expensive very accurate .45s in a cheap rig.
  7. S&W are good revolvers. I have seen police trade in Glocks for about $350.
  8. Berto

    Berto woo woo

    Low on zoot factor, but a K frame S&W .38 is still an excellent self defense handgun, about as proven as they get.
  9. Berto

    Berto woo woo

    Oh yeah, the NY-1 is a great shooter... but if you're new to DA revolver shooting, it will take getting used to. Once you do master DA revolver though, you'll find those skills transfer to other handguns nicely.


  10. Bruce M

    I agree that a K frame is a great revolver. I also think though that in some ways a Glock that might be had at 350 or a Ruger 9mm for less than 300 could be an even better deal when the ammunition cost is factored in.
  11. G36's Rule

    G36's Rule Senior Member

    CompleteNerd, what state are you in? You said CHL so I thought maybe Texas, but need you to clarify.

    My question has a point, if you are a Texan.
  12. G36,
    I'm up in Washington actually. So technically I believe I should have said CPL. A little mistake while I was trying to get my thoughts in order.

    And thanks everybody, I more or less wanted to get the thoughts of the more experienced before I sprung that way. It looks like buds has model 10s for 269 right now so I may just swing that way as well.
    #11 CompleteNerd, Sep 25, 2012
    Last edited: Sep 25, 2012
  13. Jason D

    Jason D INFRINGED!
    Silver Member Millennium Member
    1. Project Mayhem
    2. Show Me Glockers

    The model 64 is one of my favorite revolvers. I have several of them all over the place.
    My Detroit Police 64 is in right next to me in my desk drawn.

    The model 64 is the stainless version of the model 10.
    While the older model 10's with the half moon front sight are a classic. When buying a used police trade in I would go stainless every time. Light scuffs can be blended out with an eraser, and you have the corrosion resistance of stainless steel.
  14. Good, solid revolvers for sure :)

  15. That is an ISSF target! Looks very familiar:cool:.

    And good results from the S&W 64, that is good shooting, as expected from you.
  16. G36's Rule

    G36's Rule Senior Member

    The reason I ask is this, if you take your CHL course in Texas with a revolver that is all you can carry. I don't know what the law is in Washington.
  17. There is a difference between "cheap" and "inexpensive". Model 64's are "inexpensive" right now.

    And they're not old...they're experienced. :supergrin:
  18. gunsmoke92

    Silver Member

    What CajunBass said! And no offense to any one, just my opinion, but I'll take a $279 S&W 64 over a $350 + Glock every day of the week. Believe me, you can't loose with a Smith.
  19. "Opinion on cheap old revolvers"

    The more I think about it the more it bothers me when you used the word "cheap" to describe S&W 64 revolvers. There is nothing cheap about them.

    How about $280 is the least expensive quality stainless steel revolver there is that is worth owning to defend yourself and love ones?
  20. Summit gun broker has g22's for 349. You might be able to pull off a win on a SP2022 for ~350 off of gunbroke.

    Jet guns has the lc9 for 338, sr9c for 402. Kahr CW40 for 340ish. Buds has all the PX4 pistols on sale right now but for 399, the new s&w sd pistols are quite inexpensive as well.
    #20 Taphius, Sep 27, 2012
    Last edited: Sep 27, 2012

Share This Page

Duty Gear at CopsPlus