Came down to the Benelli M2 Tactical and the Remington 870 Nighthawk. I really enjoyed both, and have a long standing love affair with the pump. But that Benelli just felt great, and with the $150 off rebate it made it an even trade for me with some stuff I was parting with and no cash in. So I did it. Shot it today and I love it. I love how smooth it is, how it feels to shoot and hold, and I like the way the Benelli unloads with the release switch and all. It's my first semi auto, too, as I only really use them for HD. But I'm very pleased.