In the market. . comparing models

Discussion in 'Tactical Shotguns' started by ric0123, Aug 9, 2014.


  1. ric0123

    ric0123
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    May 28, 2004
    362
    1
    Location:
    North Austin, Texas
    I may be in the market for a new home defense shotty. I've been reading the threads here and I know I'm going to open a can of worms but asking for favorites and recommendations but I'm going to do it anyway.

    I have an NEF right now (which I have heard is an 870 clone). At the time I bought it I was also looking at a mossy maverick but I didn't like the way the fore grip felt.

    My bigger concern is tube capacity, or lack there of. I was reading about problems with tube extensions so I've decided I want a single piece. I have been looking at the mossberg persuader and also the 590a1 special purpose. I really want at least 7+1 but I'm fairly certain I want it in a single piece tube. Apparently certain model numbers are factory installed +2 and some are single piece. The 590a1 has other features like the sites and fiber front end.

    I'm not overly worried about price (though I'm not really wanting to drop 1200 on a banelli). Assume for a minute that this will be your only long gun, because it would be my only non handgun.

    Based on that, let the can of worms be opened !
     

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. Inebriated

    Inebriated
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Feb 20, 2012
    2,400
    34
    First, if you buy a good extension, you'll have no issues. I have about a thousand rounds through a Wilson Combat +2 on one 870, and not a single hiccup or loosening. So don't worry too much about it if the gun you want requires one.

    That said, obviously a one-piece is always more inherently reliable. Remington's newest 870 HD and Tactical models do come with a one-piece 6-round magazine tube. The issue with that is, you can't just take any 870 barrel and throw it on. You have to have one with the ring further forward for the longer magazine tube (same holds true for the 6/7+1 Mossbergs, I believe).

    If you want it for HD, the range, the occasional round of clays, some hunting, then you'll be fine with the 18.5" barrel on it. If you think you might get into duck hunting, or more frequent clays, or might want to start shooting sabot slugs, then just get an 870 or 500/590 with the 4-round tube, and run a quality extension, because you'll get that added barrel versatility.

    I'm an 870 guy, and if I were in the market for one shotgun (and for a long time, that's all I had), it'd be an 870.

    JD at AI&P (member here) does a good Express upgrade package, and brings it to-spec with the Police model while costing less. The Basic 1 I believe is the model.
     

    #2 Inebriated, Aug 9, 2014
    Last edited: Aug 9, 2014
  3. Cain8768

    Cain8768
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Nov 24, 2012
    181
    2
  4. Buffering

    Buffering
    Expand Collapse
    The Cooler

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2005
    768
    8
    Location:
    Rocking the Casbah
    Just to add to what you said and to give the OP something else to munch on, JD just finished building me an 870/20 and it's a fine piece of machinery. It's specifically called the Basic 20 however it's also available as a Basic 12. If I were in the market for a basic and solid HD/SD gun, you can't do much better.
     
  5. tango44

    tango44
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jun 16, 2005
    5,067
    26
    Location:
    Miami Florida
    Rem 870 enough said!
     
  6. xnicodemusx

    xnicodemusx
    Expand Collapse
    Custom fitted

    Joined:
    Aug 16, 2012
    286
    15
    Location:
    Tampa, Fl
    Fn slp mk1
     
  7. DFin

    DFin
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Mar 22, 2008
    2,065
    0
    .....
     
    #7 DFin, Aug 16, 2014
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2014
  8. g17rem870

    g17rem870
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Aug 21, 2014
    1
    0
    Location:
    North Bay
    Hey DFin please go on do you feel as the 20 has some advantage... the Wilson combat scatter gun tech build I'm looking at didn't seem to be able to get an extra round into the extension tube .... is there a ballistic advantage? Thx in advance E
     
  9. mtstream

    mtstream
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Aug 14, 2014
    530
    26
    Location:
    Dallas, TX
    You threw a wrench into the whole thing when you said "only long gun." For HD I want maneuverability, I don't care about chokes due to expected distances, I want a grip that I can hold well with one hand while opening a door with the other, etc. etc.

    But "only long gun" I would want versatility. You didn't mention if you would want to buy additional barrels or really wanted one gun/one configuration. At a minimum this would mean a longer barrel (I think 20") with chokes. I think states vary on if you can use a removable plug in the mag for hunting or not - someone with more knowledge on that will have to weigh in.

    As far as which gun - personally I own a Benelli M4 and Vinci along with an 870. My one gun would be the M4 because it behaves like a rifle (and has chokes) even though it is only 18.5" (BTW my skeet range won't allow barrels under 20"). But it's a very hefty price tag. Outside of that, I would stick with an 870 - tried and true, lots of options and lots of parts available.
     
  10. hunter 111

    hunter 111
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    2,168
    5
    Location:
    TRAVEL -
    Pleaee
    Quality control plastic parts makes this a horrible choice
    Unless he gnet a police model or wing master

    Best most duable is the Mossburg line
    590 sounds like what you are looking for
    Get a marinecote if you aren't tactical oriented
     
  11. Inebriated

    Inebriated
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Feb 20, 2012
    2,400
    34
    If you can't spell them, why would anyone take your critique seriously?

    If you want to rehash 870 v 590, just search. Most of us who actually shoot shotguns know that the differences are greatly exaggerated by those who don't.
     
  12. Leigh

    Leigh
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    May 22, 2000
    2,463
    7
    Location:
    Eastern Kentucky
    Ouch...that's going to leave a mark.

    In 30+ years of shotgunning, I've encountered some winners and a few losers.

    As for any 870 vs. 590 debate, it generally comes to to one factor; personal preference.

    I had a 590A1 and tried to like it but could not. The weight of the heavy-wall barrel and 9-shot capacity made it wayyyyy too heavy for me. Reliable? You bet!

    Tacticool features aside, an 870 Wingmaster with standard mag tube and 18-20 inch bead sight barrel will likely cover 99.999999% of anyone's HD needs. Period.

    I would suggest possibly a forearm/barrel mounted high-intensity light but that would be all.

    IMO, leave the ghost rings, heat shields, slings, sidesaddles, red dots, and picatinny rails to other firearms.
     
    #12 Leigh, Aug 26, 2014
    Last edited: Aug 26, 2014
  13. Mochahooligan

    Mochahooligan
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Dec 12, 2004
    1,000
    5
    Location:
    Chicago West burbs
    Remington 870 a lll day long!
     
  14. ca survivor

    ca survivor
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2011
    8,335
    29
    Location:
    Florida
    another vote for the Remington 870
     
  15. phalanxr

    phalanxr
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Oct 29, 2011
    407
    13
    I have a 10 year old Mossy 500 cruiser that bounced around in a trunk. Its scratched, gouged, banged up, the bolt inside has gouges, idk what from.

    Yet it runs like a proverbial sewing machine. The controls are intuitive and after slapping on magpul furniture I can never see myself getting rid of it outside a 590A1 with ghost rings.
     
  16. Big Bird

    Big Bird
    Expand Collapse
    NRA Life Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2003
    8,793
    386
    Location:
    Louisville KY
    I don't know why anyone would complain about plastic components on a shotgun on a website dedicated to plastic pistols....

    From an aesthetics standpoint...OK the Aluminum might be classier--a little bit.

    When it comes to the plastic trigger group on an 870 I've never seen one fail. I've used a bunch of em too. I own a couple of Benelli's with plastic trigger groups that have been through hell and back and never have given me one bit of a problem. So the use of polymer in a shotgun is proven to be reliable and has several advantages over aluminum.

    Honestly...with any quality shotgun from Mossberg, Remington etc materials selection will generally not be an issue. Fit and finish--maybe.
     
    #16 Big Bird, Aug 28, 2014
    Last edited: Aug 28, 2014

Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Glock models in the the New Year? General Glocking Nov 10, 2015
Why this difference in the models General Glocking Jan 6, 2014
In The Market! GATE Self-Defense Forum Jan 2, 2012
In the market need feedback Rimfire Forum Jan 11, 2011
Hottest ammunition in the market?! Caliber Corner Jul 12, 2010
Duty Gear at CopsPlus