Privacy guaranteed - Your email is not shared with anyone.

Welcome to Glock Forum at

Why should YOU join our forums?

  • Reason #1
  • Reason #2
  • Reason #3

Site Description

I Need Your Help: Sig Sauer 522, S&W M&P 15-22, or Ruger 10/22?

Discussion in 'Rimfire Forum' started by Flipz, Jan 30, 2010.

  1. Flipz


    Nov 9, 2009
    Hey guys,

    Ive been interested in getting a semi-auto .22LR rifle for awhile now and Im trying to decide between these 3 choices:

    Sig Sauer 522
    S&W M&P 15-22
    Ruger 10/22

    If you have experience with any of these and have suggestions as to which one to purchase please post. Im looking for all your opinions, good or bad.

    Im leaning towards the Sig and I have heard good things about it. But I have not made up my mind yet and am looking for a little help from you guys.

    What do you think? Which one should I buy?
  2. FLIPPER 348

    FLIPPER 348 Happy Member

    Oct 7, 2000
    Bend Oregon
    I have the S&W and the Ruger. The S&W is cooler and looks/acts just like an AR. The Ruger is a better rifle all around. I like my GSG-5 better than both!

  3. That's an odd assortment of choices. For the price of either of the first 2, you could get a few of the others.

    After I got my Ruger 10/22 working, I swore I would never buy another Ruger: and I won't. BUT, in your situation, for the price of a Sig or SW, you could get a Marlin, a Savage, and a Remington. The Marlin, Savage, and Remington are better than the Ruger.

    If you like a QC challenge, the Ruger is for you. If you just want to shoot, go with a Savage or Marlin. But if you want something unique, go with the Sig or SW.
  4. Flipz


    Nov 9, 2009
    Im looking for more of a tactical look. Im also looking at the Kel Tec SU-22. Its gonna be a tough decision. Im still leaning towards the Sig. Whatever I choose is gonna be my first .22lr rifle and its gonna be a range/plinking/fun gun. Just something to change it up a bit at the range while also being much less expensive when it comes to ammo.
  5. Well, if you are looking for something to compliment your 5.11 pants, Thunderkiller shirt, your Level IV body armor with sewn in rear plate, Delta Force boots, and Blackwater Red Cell Ballistic Shield, and Jeep assault vehicle with a Hemi.....

    don't forget the GSG 5.
  6. venenoindy


    Jul 13, 2004
    I have all three, and apples to oranges. the 10/22 IMO while a great rifle is not a true training (plinker) sub for an AR. I do have an AR and the S&W M&P15-22 does a great job as a cheaper alternative and training tool for me to be a lot more familiar with the big brother, the Sig is also a great rifle but also different feel than the AR platform. to me the M&P15-22 is a lot easier to get accesories because of the vast options of the AR platform, the Sig there is not a whole lot out there and if there is, will be more expensive.I like each for different reasons but if I could only have one it would be the M&P15-22.
  7. Making a fair comparison really depends on which model of 10/22... the new Ruger SR22 compares well to the S&W 15-22 and Sig 522.

    I own all three and the SR22 offers an AR feel, and the ability to accept any AR furniture. It generally needs a bit of trigger work, but other than that it offers a very reliable platform with lots of after-market support. There are no iron sights, and the short rail pretty much limits you to an optical sight of some sort. Cost $450

    The S&W 15-22 is a great trainer for any center-fire AR as it's controls are identical. It also needs a trigger job IMO, and can accept most AR collapsible stocks and grips. The fore-end is not readily changed out. The rifle comes with a pretty good set of removable A2 style iron sights. Cost $400

    The Sig 522 is a great clone of their 556 rifle, with solid construction and identical controls. It doesn't have much after-market support... yet. It does have the best trigger out of the box, and really doesn't need much help. Like the Ruger you are pretty much limited to optical sights as it comes with a short top rail. Cost $420

    To me, it's a matter of handling each one and then deciding which one you like the best. They all offer similar accuracy and the fun factor is high with each one.

    If I could only have one, I'd likely be just as crotchety as ol' Rooster! :supergrin:

    Good luck.
    Last edited: Jan 31, 2010
  8. gnepig

    gnepig Remember

    Oct 13, 2009

    I agree with Rooster, (unless I get one really really cheap) I will not buy another 10/22.
  9. M2 Carbine

    M2 Carbine

    Dec 21, 2002
    That's what I told my friend.

    Of the three if I had to make a choice it would be the S&W simply because it feels and operates like a AR. Mine had paid for itself in .223 ammo savings in a couple months.

    The SIG is a very good rifle but SIG didn't include iron sights with the gun or even any bolt on rails for the forearm.

    The 10/22? Everyone should own a 10/22.

    I think you will be satisfied with whichever one you get.
  10. Flipz


    Nov 9, 2009
    I am not looking for an AR trainer. Just a fun gun to shoot at the range while spending less on ammo.

    Both the Sig and the S&W have the looks and performance I want so its really between them now.
    The Sig having the metal upper makes me lean that way. And you can always order the rails that attach to the front handguards straight from Sig if you want. I don't care that it doesn't come with iron sights as I will be using a red dot most likely. Plus it doesn't use a proprietary mag. Black Dog made the magazines for Sig so any Black Dog mags will work in it.
    I think I've just convinced myself that the Sig is the right way to go. Lol!
    Now I know a lot of you AR fans would have said to go for the S&W since it looks and operates like the .223 AR. But that doesn't concern me. I just want a .22lr rifle that is fun to shoot and doesn't look half bad either.

    I'm still open to suggestions and opinions. Please feel free to comment.
  11. Can't argue with any of your reasoning, as I like my 522 quite alot!

  12. chineseboxer


    Jan 30, 2009
    New England
    My S&W has been an absolute blast to shoot. After a couple hundred rounds it is flawless with most bulk ammo, It seems to like Federal the best. I put about 400 rounds thru it last week with one FTF. This was ammo malfunction not gun. Mags are fairly cheap as well.
  13. Darkangel1846


    Jul 19, 2004
    Well I went to three of my gun stors...two have gun smiths. I just asked which rifle have they had to send back the most. It seems that the Colt has a problem although it is the most realistic looking of them all. The rated the Sig and S&W as very good and leaned towards the S&W as the mags were cheaper. So I ordered the S&W and several mags, sure hope the murphy doesn't bite me on the butt.
  14. Faulkner

    Faulkner Patriot Millennium Member

    Aug 21, 1999
    Arkansas Ozarks
    I have a GSG-5, S&W 15-22, and a Ruger 10-22. No experiance with the Sig. I like all three of mine, but if I could only pick one I'd stick with the S&W 15-22. Mine has been reliable, accurate, simple to field strip and clean, and easy to accessorize.

  15. dw_player


    Jan 1, 2009
    Lexington, KY
    I own the Smith. I looked at the Colt didn't like it. Everything I've read post purchase said I made the right decision there.
    I haven't shot the Sig. The only recommendation I can make is read about cleaning. I'm pretty sure I've read on here (somewhere?) that the Sig is bear to clean? Though I may be confusing it with the Colt.
    Someone please correct me if I'm wrong here.
    Definately can't go wrong with the Smith though. Paid $389 for mine at a show.
    If price doesn't matter then it's probably a wash. You will definately spend extra cash on the Sig for some type of sights.
  16. The Sig 522 is easy to take down for cleaning.. the Colt/Umarex is NOT.

    The latest S&W 15-22s come with threaded barrels and A2 flash hiders, making them look even better, IMO.
  17. wingspar


    Oct 7, 2009
    The 10/22 is the cheapest alternative, and a great gun. I like mine. But, it’s obvious you want the AR look, so if you are interested in the Sig, Nutnfancy spent a lot of time at the Sig booth during SHOT, and spent some time looking at the Sig 522. Here is his YouTube video. The 522 comes at about the 22 minute 30 second time in the video. Nutnfancy is long winded, but does good reviews.
  18. Flipz


    Nov 9, 2009
    Oh trust me, I watched the video he did at the Sig booth. Im just waiting for him to put up the review he did on the 522 that he talked about in the video. Ive checked his page and its not up yet.
    I went to the range today and checked out the Sig. I didnt get to shoot it as they dont have it as a rental, but I got to handle it and check it out. It feels very solid. The bolt operated very smoothly. Fit and finish was great. Just overall looked like a very well put together gun.
    I think I may be buying my first Sig.
  19. wingspar


    Oct 7, 2009
    Try the search feature on Nutnfancy’s main page. It seems like I’ve seen him do some shooting with the Sig. He probably hasn’t done one of his “Table Top” reviews on the gun yet, but I certain I’ve seen him shooting the Sig 522. He has so many videos, but his search feature works.
  20. Flipz


    Nov 9, 2009
    I tried the search feature on his page but couldnt find anything. Wish he would post the table top review already,lol.