Hot Loads in a K Frame?

Discussion in 'The Wheelhouse' started by District18, Oct 8, 2012.


  1. I've heard it before, don't run a lot of hot loads through a K frame, but I was wondering if anyone here has. Specifically I have a model 65 ladysmith 3". I'm wondering how hot can I go without trashing my gun? Are Buffalo Bores heavy .357 loads out of the question?
     

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. Loading...

    Similar Threads Forum Date
    Magnum loads in a j frame GATE Self-Defense Forum Jun 20, 2015
    Large frame Glock trigger not resetting on hot loads The 10 Ring Apr 22, 2014
    Defensive loads for a j-frame GATE Self-Defense Forum Mar 11, 2012
    Can max 10mm loads beat up the G20 frame? Reloading Feb 29, 2012
    Anyone here use AA# 5 for .44mag. loads? Reloading Friday at 4:43 PM

  3. CanMan

    Silver Member

    1,122
    7

    I haven't put a lot of 'hot loads' through my Model 19, but then again I'm not a real fan of max/hot loads anyway. I don't think a moderate diet of the hot stuff will hurt anything. Let forcing cone and top strap erosion be the limiting factor...the hotter the load, the more it's gonna happen. Recoil usually dictates the number of hot loads I want to shoot! :wavey:
     

  4. I too shoot/carry a 3' 65 among several "K" frames and have been shooting some since the '70s. I paid close attention to this issue when it was a "current" topic. I have explained it a coouple dozen times and have finally come to a "simple explanation that saves me time, to wit:

    The problem arises with 125 gn and lighter bullets driven at magnum velocities since these projectiles lack the momentum to transition from cylinder to forcing cone in a smooth" manner. They tend to hesitate in the forcing cone until the pressure "bumps" them on their way. This puts pressure on the forcing cone it was not intended to absorb. That coupled with the flat taken off the bottom of the forcing cone increase the potential for cracking. It also explains the flame cutting of the topstrap as the pressure vents at the cylinder gap.

    The heavier 158 gn bullets seem to transition smoother and are far less prone to this issue.

    Many people have argued this, but it is easy for someone who reloads to test the theory.

    Given the range from low .38 loads to top .357 loads it is easy to find a load of a favorite powder that is safe for both 125 gn and 158 gn bullets (final velocity is unimportant.) load a few cases with each bullet weight and the same amount of powder behind both and then have someone else fire them on a darkened range while you observe the flash at the barrel/cylinder gap. If the explanation (theory) is incorrect there should be no difference between the flash, but if it is correct it will be obvious. (BTW I suggest 2400 for the powder, it gives a very satisfactory demonstration of the principle.)
     
    #3 countrygun, Oct 14, 2012
    Last edited: Oct 24, 2012
  5. Thanks guys for the input.
     
  6. gunsmoke92

    Silver Member

    2,441
    28
    countrygun and CanMan have given you a lot of good information.

    Now let me try and give you some more concerning your last question. The last thing I would run through any K frame is Buffalo Bore. Don't get me wrong, Buffalo Bore is great ammo, if you're sporting an L or N frame Smith, or a Ruger. You need to understand that the K frames were originally .38s modified to accept the new .357 cartridge, hence the flat undercut in the forcing cone area which allowed for installation of the larger crane and cylinder. The completely redesigned L frame guns corrected that weakness. Get one of those if you're really into "hot" loads, save your K frame for something a little more pleasant and it will serve you well for many years to come.
     
    #5 gunsmoke92, Oct 21, 2012
    Last edited: Oct 21, 2012
  7. I would never run Buffalo Bore through a K frame.
     

Share This Page

Duty Gear at CopsPlus