CCW: One in the chamber or not?

Discussion in 'Carry Issues' started by ArlenGunClub, Jan 24, 2013.


Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. This. It looks, feels and sounds foolish and mall ninjaesque (yes, I make up words) but I have practiced drawing my gun properly from my IWB, shoulder holster and BH Serpa thousands of times each. And each time I do it I make a point to follow the "Booger hook off the bang stick" rule.

    If it becomes so ingrained that you cannot force yourself to place your finger in the trigger guard until you're on target....you're almost there, practice a bit more.

    It also has the advantage of informing you what the limitations of time and position are in reference to your chosen carry method and cover clothing.
     

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. tnedator

    Lifetime Member

    546
    0
    386
    Well, heck, why not just lock every thread? Shucks, why even have a discussion forum at all? You can find opinion on virtually every topic via Google that's in old forum threads, Twitter or blogs/articles.

    I think we should petition GT to have an "auto-close" feature five minutes after any thread is created. /sarcasm

    Ok, sorry, shouldn't have done it, but it's a pet peeve of mine when the forum police want to dictate which topics are worthy of discussion on a DISCUSSION forum.

    I wanted to highlight this part of your post. It was all good, but wanted to bring attention to this. Far too often people practice, or simply assume, the best case scenarios. What happens when you have a concealment garment and winter coat? What about when you wear tucked shirt (assuming you do)? What about when you are sitting? In the car with the seat belt fastened?

    Each of these, and many other situations, create completely unique draw scenarios, and take varying amounts of time. If you are seated and your shirt is too long, you can be sitting on it, and might not be able to rip it up in a clean ripping motion. There are so many factors.

    So, whether you are practicing with an unloaded gun, or a Blue rings gun that is the same model as your gun (good overall, but doesn't properly replicate weight), you need to not only make the general draw stroke second nature (start here), but then in addition to continuing to practice to not lose the draw stroke, you need to start practicing drawing from less than ideal positions, clothing, etc.
     

  3. ICARRY2

    ICARRY2 NRA Life Member

    Carry chamber empty. That way you'll look like a bad ass racking the slide in front of the bad guy right before he shoots you. :rolleyes:
     
  4. Several advantages for chamber carry plus a few disadvantages.

    1) Simplicity. No need to add another step to get the weapon in action.

    2) Immediate first shot in the shortest time period, especially from retention position (that is grabbing distance.)


    3) No need for two hands to chamber. You may have one hand hurt or busy and not be able to use two hands.

    Grappling with an attacker also makes chambering with two hands rather tough. Opponent may slam you to the ground, or grab the weapon, or just punch you while you try to chamber a round.


    4) When under pressure you might short stroke the action and jam the weapon.

    The downside is that if you forget the gun is loaded you can pull the trigger and have a AD/ND (but then, just KYFFOTFT till the weapon is on target.) Yes there are AD/NDs every year. No doubt many have their weapons chamber loaded, but then many are ‘cleaning’ their weapons and well, who knows what state their weapons was really in.

    Now chamber empty (C3) has a few advantages.

    1) A gun snatch will give you a few seconds for the BG to react (you hope) to get the weapon back.


    2) If you have kids, and the slide is hard to rack, it's less chancy of they get the gun somehow (but then I feel you should just pick the gun up, ok.)

    3) If your gun is not drop safe, then chamber empty is the best way to carry.

    4) No safe way to carry the weapon (lack of holster, poor holster, etc..)

    5) If you tend to take your gun out and play with it instead of keeping it holstered then C3 might be a better way to carry. (not kidding, there are people that do mess with their weapons like that.)

    Overall, chamber empty is an inferior technique for most people.

    There are some where it serves a purpose like having the weapon hidden around the house and you have time to chamber a round, but for most, chamber loaded is the better technique for a defensive handgun.

    Now why is C3 inferior?

    Because of the extra steps one has to take that mostly require two hands under very stressful conditions.

    Yes I am aware you can chamber one handed but can one do this quickly and reliably adverse conditions? I do mean quick and reliable, say when grapping with an attacker? Or with various simi-autos that are produced now?

    Or in the rain? Or while moving? I doubt it.

    One doubts it, right? Doing a one handed rack on a square range on a sunny day isn't the same thing as on the street when things are going down hill quickly.

    Is chamber empty safer to carry in the light of ND/ADs?

    It is difficult so see how it is safer if you keep the weapon in a proper holster that covers the trigger guard and has adequate retention (in case of a fall or such) and don/doff with the weapon in the holster.

    That way the trigger cannot be pulled in any way.

    But wither one carries their weapon C1 or C3, it is very important to train to be safe.

    If you cannot keep your weapon holstered until needed, don't carry C1, and if you tend to fumble chambering a weapon fast, don't carry C3 (and for BOTH C1 and C3, if you can't keep your finger off the trigger until the need to fire, leave the gun home!) Training is the most important part.

    Ignorance is what causes AD/NDs, not the state of the weapon.

    Deaf
     
  5. This subject has been beaten to death on every forum etc.Bottom line anyone who fears caring with one in the chamber.? I strongly suggest that they start caring a Revolver.? Case Closed.
     
  6. Poppa Bear

    Poppa Bear Protective G'pa
    CLM

    949
    0
    736
    My suggestion as some have already noted is for you, meaning any poster or reader of this post, to PRACTICE!!! I do not care if you want to carry chamber empty, or loaded. Just practice whichever technique you plan to use until it becomes an ingrained memory.

    My primary carry is a G22. My primary and secondary competitive guns are a 2011 and a 1911. I am so used to swiping the safety off that I try to take one off on my Glock. This translates to my thumb coming down into position as my strong hand grips the gun in a manner that will wipe the safety off even though it is not there.

    My 2011 is competition only. My 1911 is easily a carry gun. I would have no problem carrying my 1911 because the muscle memory is there to draw the gun, remove the safety, and then place my finger on the trigger as it indexes on the target for an active engagement situation, or along side the frame when dealing with a non shooting situation. As long as I have no intention of firing the gun my finger is on the frame. When I plan to fire it subconsciously drops into place on the trigger. This is in a large part due to thousands of repetitions over a 20 year + time span. So do things however you want, but practice the hell out of it.
     
    #106 Poppa Bear, Jan 25, 2013
    Last edited: Jan 26, 2013
  7. One in the chamber and DON'T call it a CLIP! It's a MAGAZINE!
     
  8. I'v already stated my own opinion and preference for one up the snout earlier. However, there is another alternative for folks who don't want to carry with a round in the chamber. However, it's not a Glock.

    There are a number of DA/SA pattern handguns out there that have the true safety lever. Sig would be an example of a decocker and Beretta B92F an example of a safety/decocker.

    For those who don't know the details, a DECOCKER safely decocks the hammer and the spring returns the decocker, trigger and firing mechanism to it's ready DA position. Pull trigger and gun fires DA mode.

    A SAFETY lever decocks the hammer, disconnects the trigger and the lever then remains in the down position (no spring loading). Pull trigger and nothing happens, also a steel block remains between the firing pin and hammer. To fire, the SAFETY lever has to be manually moved upwards and the trigger pulled.

    In other words, if you don't like a live round chambered, a DA/SA with a true safety would effectively give you the same level of comfort as an empty chamber. The trigger is disconnected and the steel block is in place. All it takes is a thumb flick up to fire, not a racking of the slide.

    This type of gun is popular with some guys that work corrections, bookings or other jobs that require the person to be armed (safety on/down), but in close proximity to bad guys that may want your gun. Of course, many shooters don't like DA/SA guns so this is not an option.

    While these types of discussions are always interesting, civilians are fortunate enough to have a wide range of individual choices. You get to make yours and I get to make mine, which is the way it should be.
     
  9. Lior

    Lior GUNS=FREEDOM

    Carrying a round in the chamber has a tactical advantage and is okay if you practice gun safety religiously.

    At the moment I carry with an empty chamber because I don't have exclusive access to the gun safe, and my assessment is that the increased safety in administrative handling from gun safe to person is worth more than the reduced safety of needing to chamber a round in a hypothetical encounter justifying and necessitating deadly force. But that's just me and YMMV. This is a temporary arrangement and I shall soon go back to a normal safe.
     
  10. Sir, you win the Internet this evening. Good post.

    And I concur. There are quality revolvers from major manufactures in every (ok, just about) caliber. Get a good revolver and a good holster and take comfort in having 5-8 shots ready to go without the need to "chamber a round".

    I carry a Kahr CM9 in a Desantis, strong side hip pocket. I always have 1 in the chamber. I try not to "handle" the firearm except to take the whole rig (holster and pistol) out of my pocket in the evening and to put it back in my pocket the next morning.

    That being said, I pocket carried a j frame for 3 years and never felt under armed.
     

  11. Good luck with that.
     
  12. This topic is just more than old. Hey, if you are going to carry a Glock for self defense for God's sake have a round in the chamber. The weapon was designed for this. If you think that you might have to rack one one in the chamber you are a complete moron. Sorry for being so blunt but how the hell else could I be.
     
  13. I carry with one in the chamber and a full mag. Former Deputy Sheriff.
     
  14. PhotoFeller

    Silver Member

    Your wisdom is automatically cancelled by your ignorance.
     
  15. NEOH212

    NEOH212 Diesel Girl

    Oh God, not again!


    :faint:
     
  16. NEOH212

    NEOH212 Diesel Girl

    If your that worried about, maybe you shouldn't be carrying a gun in the first place....:whistling:
     
  17. fallenangelhim

    fallenangelhim come get some

    289
    0
    136
  18. happyguy

    happyguy Man, I'm Pretty

    Not even close.

    Regards,
    Comrade Happyguy :)
     
  19. Poppa Bear

    Poppa Bear Protective G'pa
    CLM

    949
    0
    736
    Jerry could carry one unloaded. Of course anyone that can do 6 reload 6 in 2.99 seconds is not your normal revolver guy. LOL
     

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page