Brass To Face! Gen 4 G17 Ejection Examined (Video)

Discussion in 'General Glocking' started by Raleigh Glocker, Oct 7, 2012.

  1. Arc Angel

    Arc Angel
    Expand Collapse
    Deus Vult!

    Sep 20, 2003
    Penn's Woods
    Sometimes I think that I've been reading GT for too long! Not all Glocks are identical: Molds are different; and, to my knowledge, many - if not all - of the internal parts are supplied on contract to Glock, GmbH/Inc. by numerous and often varying outside manufacturers. Comments to the effect that Glock pistols exhibit a wide range of different mechanical tolerances have been frequently posted on this board by many different gunsmiths and aftermarket parts suppliers.

    I, also, get tired of reading over and over again that Glock problems should, most correctly, be blamed on shooters who: (1) limp wrist, or (2) use the wrong ammunition. I used and fired pistols for a good 50 years BEFORE I began hearing about everybody's problems with plastic pistols and limp wristing.

    (Yes! When compared to the John M. Browning designed pistols I grew up with, Glock's SIGNIFICANTLY MODIFIED, 'Browning lockup' is, indeed, extraordinarily loose AND extraordinarily susceptible to ....... limp wristing!) :supergrin:

    Heck, I still remember the days when we all used to just walk into an Army-Navy store, buy whatever surplus pistol ammo was on the shelves, (at well under $5 per 50 count box) take it to the range, shoot it off, and go home. Terms like, 'limp wristing' and, 'the wrong ammo' weren't in anybody's firearms lexicon! We only knew one word, 'Bang!' and the most common expression was, 'Watch your front sight!'

    (I guess those days are gone forever, though, huh!) :)

    Neither do I believe that, 'Glock can't fix its problems'. Bricks are bricks; and mortar is mortar! In my viewpoint the real problem with Glock pistols that don't, or won't, work right is, for lack of better words, 'Teutonic frugality'. Glock pistols are very inexpensive to manufacture and cheap to sell. In my opinion, the gun buying American public would do well to view Glock pistols in this way.

    (Even at an astonishing $650 + dollars a unit it's, probably, only too true: Sometimes, you really do get what you pay for. It's just that in my short lifetime I can still easily recall purchasing flawless Colt Mark IV's and, 'Gold Cups' for between $330.00 and $425.00! We never had no limp wristing nor ammunition problems with any of them.) :freak:

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. eracer

    Expand Collapse
    Where's my EBT?

    Apr 5, 2011
    Tampa, FL

    Criticism of the shooter's choice of gloves serves no purpose except to massage the critic's ego.

    And minor faults in his stance/grip have nothing / nada / zero to do with the BTF issue. Again, pointless critique.

  3. Raleigh Glocker

    Raleigh Glocker
    Expand Collapse

    Oct 16, 2010
    Three Guesses
    Glock watched the videos and didn't seem to think it was a form or ammo problem. :) They replaced every single part in the whole gun except the frame, the slide, the barrel, sights, and cover plate. I sent this to them on their dime, and I got it back in exactly one week. I'd say they took this pretty seriously and have so far impressed me with their efforts. Of course, that means nothing if the new parts don't correct the problem.

    Interestingly enough, the new ejector and RSA are the same numbers, and the new extractor is still a "dip" extractor. I asked the warranty tech about reports that some were getting non-"dip" extractors as part of their warranty work, and he said that he hadn't heard about that but would look into it.

    I won't be able to get to the range until Wednesday of next week, at the earliest. I will make a brief follow-up video, including another slow motion shot of the ejection.
  4. 4949shooter

    Expand Collapse
    1. The JBT's

    Aug 14, 2006
    New Jersey Republik
    Thanks for the update.

    Good luck..
  5. Bayou

    Expand Collapse

    Mar 8, 2011
    edited to start a new thread
    #145 Bayou, Dec 31, 2012
    Last edited: Dec 31, 2012

Similar Threads Forum Date
Brass to face with Kimber General Glocking Nov 6, 2015
Summary of Brass to Face General Glocking Oct 16, 2015
G23 Gen4 Brass to Face General Glocking Aug 26, 2015
Brass to the face help me understand General Glocking Aug 8, 2015
Anyone w/G19 brass to face in Dallas? General Glocking Mar 4, 2015
Duty Gear at CopsPlus