Best defense caliber of all time...

Discussion in 'Caliber Corner' started by rohanreginald, Feb 18, 2012.


  1. rohanreginald

    rohanreginald
    Expand Collapse
    Novice

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2009
    1,339
    6
    Today I had a thought about handgun cartridges and figured since we have arrived with certain calibers through evolution, there must be a single handgun cartridge which is the overall best.

    So I was thinking that there have been famous shootouts that have caused significant change in handgun calibers such as the 1986 FBI Miami shootout. These incidents have helped the evolution of certain calibers. So here goes my thoughts.

    The 10mm came into existence in the early 80's. Shortly after the Miami shootout occurred and FBI adopted the 10mm. The 10mm was too powerful for standard issue so it was dropped by FBI. However the 10mm had certain desirable characteristics such as better trajectory and range than the big ol .45. So the .40 S&W was created to address recoil.

    The 40.S&W was then considered by some to have lost velocity so the .40 was then evolved into the .357 sig. This is where current evolution ends so the .357 Sig must be the best defense handgun caliber.

    But wait...

    So too has the .45 ACP evolved. The .45 ACP has evolved into the .45 GAP. The GAP retains the same characteristics as the ACP but in a shortened cartridge which allows for many more platforms for this cartridge.

    So in reality the .357 Sig and the .45 GAP have evolved the most. Therefore the .357 Sig and .45 GAP must be the all time best handgun cartridges.

    Since the .357 Sig is really shooting a 9mm projectile this ironically this brings us right back to the 9mm vs .45 debate. Any thoughts?
     

    Wanna kill these ads? We can help!
  2. cowboy1964

    cowboy1964
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2009
    18,052
    972
    Location:
    U.S.A.
    125 gr at 1350 fps or 230 gr at 850 fps. I don't want to get hit with either or anything in between.
     

    #2 cowboy1964, Feb 18, 2012
    Last edited: Feb 18, 2012
  3. John Biltz

    John Biltz
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2010
    1,203
    23
    Location:
    Phoenix, AZ
    Just because something is new doesn't make it the best. Being old doesn't mean its the best either. Miami was more about bad tactics than a weak round. But the FBI was not going to admit that. The FBI does not like admitting mistakes.
     
  4. collim1

    collim1
    Expand Collapse
    Shower Time!

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2005
    6,643
    182
    Location:
    USA
    .38spl+p LSWCHP has been performing for longer than any round I can think of at the moment. I cant think of any load that is unchanged for as long as still considered a viable option.

    I like .38spl and have been carrying it for years. I started carrying the Gold Dot Short Barrel load a few years ago, but would have no problems going back to the old FBI load.
     
  5. PrecisionRifleman

    PrecisionRifleman
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jan 24, 2011
    1,372
    4
    10mm is the best self defense auto cartridge unless your a pansy! :tongueout:
     
  6. Quarter Tank

    Quarter Tank
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2011
    503
    0
    Location:
    ATL
    230gr FMJ .45
     
  7. dkf

    dkf
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Aug 6, 2010
    5,321
    68
    Pfft .25acp is where its at.
     
    #7 dkf, Feb 18, 2012
    Last edited: Feb 18, 2012
  8. bdcremer

    bdcremer
    Expand Collapse
    The No SpinZone

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2005
    510
    30
    Location:
    Metro Atlanta, GA
    I see the 357sig & 45GAP as progress but this does not mean the other flavors aren't effective.
     
  9. RMTactical

    RMTactical
    Expand Collapse
    www.AR15pro.net
    CLM

    Joined:
    Oct 7, 2000
    12,603
    13
    Location:
    Behind an AR-15
    hard to beat the 9mm IMO, despite it's limitations.
     
  10. JimBianchi

    JimBianchi
    Expand Collapse
    Da Da
    CLM
    1. The Outpost Lounge

    Joined:
    Feb 15, 2006
    6,067
    163
    Location:
    Las Vegas
    9mm probably has more kills than any other round. (Germans started in and most of the world carries it now, so it wins buy sheer numbers)

    357Mag was carried for a decade or better by so many police forces is the US it many have the most one stop shots on record. Again a numbers game.

    38SP have been around since 1898, lots of stops.

    Of the modern rounds you can pick any and be safe. Modern bullet designs make them all very effective. (9mm, 10mm, 11mm (45ACP) 357SIG 40SW, 38SP, 357Mag, 44SP and 44mag or even 45LC, if you must. And of course some carry the 50AE!!)
     
  11. Rev.357

    Rev.357
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jan 14, 2012
    436
    0
    Location:
    Heath Springs SC
    if my math is good:cool:

    .45, 230gr @ 850fps = 369ft-lbs/ke

    .357sig, 124gr @1350 = 502ft-lbs/ke

    I think the sig wins
     
  12. 9mm +p+

    9mm +p+
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Mar 1, 2005
    1,720
    14
    Location:
    KS
    The best caliber? The one you have on you when you need it,9,40,357sig or mag,45 any and all will do the job IF you do yours.
     
  13. vtbluegrass

    vtbluegrass
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Dec 1, 2009
    667
    1
    Since we didn't specify handgun calibers I am going with 50BMG. Nothing says "get of my lawn" like the business end of a ma duece. hahaha
     
  14. KARTMAN90

    KARTMAN90
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Mar 18, 2011
    152
    0
    Location:
    Yuma, AZ
    Defense caliber? I'll go with a 12 gauge


    Outdoor Hub mobile, the outdoor information engine
     
  15. PrecisionRifleman

    PrecisionRifleman
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jan 24, 2011
    1,372
    4
    That's always my choice when at the house as well. Love my 870 Police.
     
  16. HiVel

    HiVel
    Expand Collapse
    HiVel

    Joined:
    Mar 26, 2003
    259
    0
    Location:
    Leeds, AL
    The 22 LR is probably the one most used-it has killed more of anything (people too) than all the rest of the non-war calibers put together.
    I have known 3 people who were killed by gunshot -all three were done in by 22LR-this is not proof just a personal story.
     
  17. greenlion

    greenlion
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2009
    936
    12
    Location:
    North Carolina
    We are talking self defense and STOPPING power her guys, not killing potential.

    If Best = most one shot stops, then the .357 magnum wins

    If best = best shot placement , then the .22lr wins

    If best = most concealable, then .380 wins

    If best = most economical, then 9mm wins

    If best = ft lbs of energy, then S&W 500 magnum wins

    If best = best compromise between size and power, .40S&W wins

    My point is they are all useful for different reasons, or we would all have guns in only one caliber, and wouldn't sit around debating which was best all day. I like 'em all.
     
  18. jaysonL

    jaysonL
    Expand Collapse

    Joined:
    Nov 14, 2009
    230
    0
    Location:
    Pa
    :goodpost::agree:
     
  19. CanyonMan

    CanyonMan
    Expand Collapse
    In The Saddle

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2002
    5,706
    9
  20. clogspecialist

    clogspecialist
    Expand Collapse
    10-head

    Joined:
    Jul 8, 2010
    79
    0
    Location:
    Cincinnati, OH
    Defense against bad people, or general defense anywhere and everywhere on earth? You just had to stop after the 10mm, with the lighter bullets (135gr going 1600fps) you are looking at the ultimate man-stopper, a commander size 10mm 1911 all de-burred and smoothed out my be the ULTIMATE caryy gun. Then you load up some 165gr hollowpoints and you can defend yourself against mountain lions. Then load up some 200gr's and can defend yourself against bigger cats like tigers in south america or lions in Africa, and then after you have came so close to death all these times you can load up some 230gr hardcast loads going 1000fps and you have protection from small bear or other enraged animals. I think 10mm has the title boys. can be loaded to 800ft-lbs in high strength handguns, and shoots very flat, and is naturally accurate.
     

Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Best Movies of All Time in These Genres Uncategorized Oct 9, 2008
Best Bands of All time Uncategorized Oct 9, 2008
Best Glock of All Time. General Glocking Feb 25, 2015
Best all around hunting caliber. Hunting, Fishing & Camping Apr 26, 2009
*All Time Best Quote* The Lighter Side Oct 1, 2007
Duty Gear at CopsPlus