What are your thoughts on back up guns? Specifically, what are your thoughts on Semi-Autos vs. Revolvers? I'm debating between the two...my semi-auto is the compact version of my duty gun, the revolver is a S&W 442. Semi Auto: Pro: Higher capacity Easier to shoot accurately at distance (vs. DAO J-frames) Quicker Reloads if needed, depending on what your duty gun is, you may have mag interchangability between the two Night sights Con: Reliability- can be pushed out of battery Weight Less concealable- Not really a factor for vest carry, but the J-frame is pocketable Revolver: Pro: Can't be pushed out of battery Reliability- "Five for sure" Weight More concealable Con: Capacity Bad sights/non-existent sights Slow reloads Harder to shoot accurately at speed (for me) Wanna kill these ads? We can help!