close

Privacy guaranteed - Your email is not shared with anyone.

Welcome to Glock Talk

Why should YOU join our Glock forum?

  • Converse with other Glock Enthusiasts
  • Learn about the latest hunting products
  • Becoming a member is FREE and EASY

If you consider yourself a beginner or an avid shooter, the Glock Talk community is your place to discuss self defense, concealed carry, reloading, target shooting, and all things Glock.

Acura TL v. Audi A4 v. Infiniti G35 v. Caddy CTS-V

Discussion in 'Car Forum' started by c5367, Aug 5, 2005.

  1. c5367

    c5367 Esq.

    1,539
    1
    Aug 1, 2003
    Indiana!
    I'm in the market for a new car and I think I've narrowed it down to these 4 models, all with a do-it-yourself gearbox and navigation. There are a few others, but a Wrangler doesn't quite fit in with these sedans. So far, I've test driven the Acura and the Audi.
    First impressions: The Acura offers a ton of amenities for the money, and I can get a pretty good deal on it. I particularly like the bluetooth handsfree system, and I'm almost to the point of considering it a must-have option. The interior is very nice. Everything is laid out almost perfectly and the fit and finish looks nearly perfect. The guages/lighting scheme are pleasant to look at as well. The car had plenty of power throuhgout the rev range, and after the VTEC switches at about 4700, its surprisingly quick for what is essentially an Accord. On the downsides, The clutch seems grabby and the shift throws were a bit long. I noticed a tiny bit of torque steer ad the turning radius is much wider than my little VW GTI. The dealer I went to didn't have a 6spd w/ nav in stock, so I didn't get a chance to push all the buttons.

    The Audi: I liked the all-red guage lighting, and the feature set is more inline with what I'd like than the Acura. The 06's, I'm told, will have a bluetooth handsfree system that will sync with your phone's phonebook, which the Acura won't do. Also, the stereo system has 2 SD card slots so you can play Mp3's. My inner geek really likes these sorts of things:) The seats were comfortable. The gearbox has shorter throws than the Acura, but I think it may be ever-so-slightly less precise feeling. I didn't test back to back, so I'm not sure. I liked the quattro system, and here in Chicago-land, I'm certain it would be nice to have in the winter.
    The interior feels a little cheaper than the Acura, or maybe "lower tech." As far as power goes, it's nowhere close to the Acura, and actually seems slower than my GTI, despite having a more powerful version of the same engine. This is probably because its putting to power to all 4 wheels and weighs a bit more. Then again, this may not be a bad thing, as I don't need anymore speeding tickets;) The nav system is a bit clumsy, but it may just require a learning curve. It could be more user friendly though. Generally, I liked the car, but I'm not sure its worth the extra cost over the TL or G35.
    I haven't driven the Infiniti or the Caddy yet. Neither has the bluetooth handsfree, which is kind of a negative, especially now that driving while talking on a cell is now a ticketable offense in the city. Both of these cars are RWD, which will be great for more spirited driving, but not-so-good in the winter. Especially the Caddy with its LS6. But then again, it's an LS6!!:D (cue Tim Taylor-esque grunting) On paper its the best performing of the group, but also the most expensive even with the extended GM-employee discount. It's also the thirstiest most expensive to insure.

    And now, my questions to y'all out there in GT-land: Does anyone have any experience with any of these rides? If so, are there any nagging little details details that bother you? Little details that you love? What about reliability? User experience in general?
    And, are there any comparable alternatives I'm missing?

    Thanks in advance for any input, and Stay Safe!
     
  2. fnfalman

    fnfalman Chicks Dig It

    50,542
    3,292
    Oct 23, 2000
    California & New Mexico, US
    My adopted dad has a TL, alas it's a slushbox version. I am not a doodads type so all of the electronic gimmicktries mean nothing to me. The Acura is a front driver and that takes a lot of fun out of what could be a great sport sedan. Nonetheless it is a lot of car for the money. The quality and fit & finish are top notch. The Audi leaves me cold. The Infinity is a great car by any standard, but somehow it also leaves me cold. It should be more fun to drive than the TL though. The Caddy, well, I would take it over the rest just because it has lots of oomph on a decently competent chassis. It ain't no BMW chassis, but it's still a good chassis thanks to Opel of Germany.
     


  3. c5367

    c5367 Esq.

    1,539
    1
    Aug 1, 2003
    Indiana!
    hmmmm...l.
    Maybe I should consider an M3..... Chicks dig Beemers :) ;z

    My objective is really all weather practicality. I'm hoping to get a 999 for my speed fixes;)
     
  4. grecco

    grecco

    2,331
    93
    Sep 12, 2004
    philadelphia pa
    the acura is most likely the best deal for the money.
    the g35 has a really good engine
    the audi is awesome,but gets really expensive to fix
    the caddy has a big strong v-8.

    there are a few things i consider when i purchase a car.
    1.reliablity
    2.value
    3.resale value
    4.fun to drive

    check out carreviews.com, sort like glocktalk for cars.....

    personally i would go w/the acura,
    i have been driving honda products for ever and they are hard to beat,
    good luck, lets us know how you do.
     
  5. epsylum

    epsylum Boolit Hoze

    3,868
    1
    Sep 4, 2004
    Racing Capital, USA
    Personally:

    Acura: the FWD ruins it for me. Good car, but WHY FWD, honda?

    Audi: definately on my list. I love VWs and Audis. Oh I would only get a manual quattro. VW is known for crappy automatics and the quattro fixes the FWD problem.

    Infiniti: I would get the G35 sport coupe. Basically a restyled (and better looking IMO) 350Z.

    Cadillac: I am not a GM man and would never own one (Vette Z06 aside).
     
  6. c5367

    c5367 Esq.

    1,539
    1
    Aug 1, 2003
    Indiana!
    I definitely agree on the FWD with the Acura. If it was RWD or even AWD, I don't think it would even be a question as to which to get.

    Right on with G35 coupe v. the 350Z. The only problem is that there isn't a manual w/ nav to be found within 100 miles of here according to infiniti's website. There are a few sedan w/ both, and the little angel on my shoulder says "more practical." But given a choice between a 6-spd coupe or sedan, the coupe wins hands down.

    Grecco,
    Thanks for the heads up on carreviews.com. I'll check it out
     
  7. milsurp

    milsurp

    320
    0
    Apr 15, 2005
    WV
    I'll be a friend and help you out here. Buy your top two. Then you and I can drive them and compare notes. Then, give me the one you like least. I wouldn't want you to have buyers remorse. Hell, use me as a tax write off and claim it's charity.
     
  8. rcm

    rcm

    6
    0
    Apr 20, 2005
    Sunapee,NH
    I own a 2002 A4. I really like this car, I had always owned American cars till I married and wife said try the Audi. I drive 70 miles a day back and forth to work so the ride has to be good. It is...I also live in NH so, I don't think I could go w/o quattro now. I have had only one small problem with the car and it was fixed under warranty. It has over 50,000 miles on it now and I drive the snot out of it. I reccomemnd this car.

    Other cars we have in the stable, wife drives mini cooper convertible with JCS package and her Colorado 4 door. My other car is a thirty year old 911. I'm not braggin' here just trying to let you know where my thoughts come from.

    Rick
     
  9. method

    method

    4,176
    257
    Mar 27, 2002
    Cleveland, OH
    The CTS-V is in a performance (and price) realm a notch or two above the others. It's the only one I've driven out of the bunch, and I like it very much....the others may be peppy, but the V is an all out beast, and can be made faster with fairly simple modifications. Keep in mind it's upwards of $15K dearer than a TL, and they eat back tires in less than 10,000 miles.
     
  10. kawalerzysta

    kawalerzysta

    266
    8
    May 10, 2004
    Mt Pocono, Pa
    I like G35, because it is RWD (AWD is optional). Caddy would be my second choice. I would stay away from Acura for being FWD and from Audi for having lousy quality.
     
  11. epsylum

    epsylum Boolit Hoze

    3,868
    1
    Sep 4, 2004
    Racing Capital, USA
    If your serious about buying a coupe, a good dealer can find one just like you want and do a dealership transfer. My dad got his Maruader that way. They just loaded it up on a truck and drove it here from another state.

    Goes to show, if you have money, people will move mountains to get it from you. ;f
     
  12. Rob1035

    Rob1035 Skeet Surfer

    895
    0
    Jan 24, 2005
    Charlotte NC
    I personally have great faith in Honda/Acura reliability. The sacrifice is of course "status" (which is meaningless to me) and "sportiness", which means a lot....

    For a daily driver, I'd like comfort that I dont have to bother with. I just dont trust the Audi like I would the Japanese offerings, especially out of warranty...

    That being said, maybe you should try an A6, as that is more inline with the other choices, and the interior and power might be more what you want.

    You might also want to check out the new Subaru Legacy GT with the 2.5 Turbo motor. Fairly quick, AWD, with a very nice interior, similar pricing to the Acura, just a thought.
     
  13. chris93473

    chris93473

    44
    0
    Aug 21, 2002
    Illinois
    i would either choose the TL or G35. it's kinda wierd how the G35 has 298hp but the 350Z is less than that. you will get more for the TL in terms of features but the G35 has much more sporting intentions to it.
     
  14. bac1023

    bac1023

    102,345
    2,709
    Sep 26, 2004
    PA
    I'd go with the TL. I love Honda/Acura reliability.
     
  15. epsylum

    epsylum Boolit Hoze

    3,868
    1
    Sep 4, 2004
    Racing Capital, USA
    +1
    But I would add to that anything from Toyota.

    Honda engineers everything to work in perfect harmony. That's how they get thier reliability. Toyota overbuilds everything and then pull it back to get reliability (notice toyota doesn't win any HP wars, they dial back the power to get the reliability).

    edited to add:

    But, man those G35 coupes look FUN!! I had an '86 300ZX non-turbo. I loved driving that car, even if it was falling apart around my ears (stupid mid 80's gadgetry, there is no reason to have my damn car TALK to me).

    The pure driving essence of that car, sold me on Z cars. If I had the money today I would own one of the 350's.

    BTW ask rockinAR if you should buy a G35.

    ;f

    http://glocktalk.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=397260
     
  16. Z28ricer

    Z28ricer

    885
    0
    Aug 4, 2005
    Tampa, FL
    I'd definetly take the V out of the choices, the G35 would be a 2nd, and wouldnt even consider the other two, provided price wasnt a deciding factor that is. The V has great styling and quality, and who can argue with an all aluminum 400 HP Gen3 backed by a T56 ? :cool:
     
  17. epsylum

    epsylum Boolit Hoze

    3,868
    1
    Sep 4, 2004
    Racing Capital, USA
    With a name like that you wouldn't be biased would you? ;f
     
  18. chris93473

    chris93473

    44
    0
    Aug 21, 2002
    Illinois
    by the way in that price range i would also say the Lexus IS350 is a good choice too. It has more hp then the G35 but the only damn thing is that the 350 only comes with a six speed auto. the 250 can be combined with a six speed standard.
     
  19. c5367

    c5367 Esq.

    1,539
    1
    Aug 1, 2003
    Indiana!
    When are the new IS's supposed to hit the showrooms?
    I've heard rumors that the IS250 will have a AWD option. Plus it will have the bluetooth and a decent audio system. Throw in a 6-spd and Lexus reliability, and I think we may have a winner.
     
  20. c5367

    c5367 Esq.

    1,539
    1
    Aug 1, 2003
    Indiana!
    A twin-turbo G35 coupe??????? ;3 ;3 ;3

    So much for practicality;f