Glock Talk banner

Ordering tonight..still undecided

2K views 51 replies 39 participants last post by  kokopelli123 
#1 ·
still trying to decide on a striker fired nightstand gun...deciding between the sig p320 compact, glock 19, Walther ppq and the HK vp9...
Worried about the light trigger on the ppq, the rubbing of the trigger finger on the HK and the newness on the market of the p320..
Had a g17 so I feel the glock is ok..
So any recommendations before ordering tonight?
 
#6 ·
I own a VP9 and a G19. The VP9 fits my hand better, and I prefer the trigger over the Glock, but I'm getting use to the Glocks trigger.

What "rubbing of the trigger finger" are you talking about with the HK? I've never had any issue with it.

I think it comes down to ergonomics and price. The G19 is a perfect size and can be carried easier than the VP9 IMO.

Both shoot great and I'd trust my life with either. Go pick them both up and buy the one you like best. There is no wrong answer here.

Put a light on either one you get.
 
#9 ·
Get a Saf-T-Block trigger dongle thingee for it. I have them on my G17 and G36.
If you are going to get a saf-t-block thingee.......then you might as well get something you can keep cocked and locked, and have a better trigger overall.

Personally, I believe it's only necessary for those who can't trust the Glock trigger, on it's own merits, to be safe enough for SD.

I have a G17 next to my bed......and, I'd trust it to save my xxx, if fate makes that necessary.
 
#11 ·
Hogship, I have a cocked and locked 1911, but got used to a in-the-pants-pocket carry for my G36 and felt I needed the Saf-T-Block trigger dongle. I got used to it and it is such an intuitive safety device, it pops out when you put your finger inside the trigger guard. My nightstand has a lot of stuff on it and I don't want an AD to happen. I think the Saf-T-Block may be an illusory device but a tiny bit of peace of mind is good to have. My nightstand gun stays loaded with 20 rounds of 124 gr +P JHP Golden Sabers. My real go-to gun is a 20 gauge Winchester Defender in the Armoire close to the bed loaded with Federal #2's. I'm a widower and have guns stashed all over the house.
 
#15 ·
I went through the same thing- deciding on the same 4 guns.
Walther PPQ is actually superior to the VP9;
I think the PPQ is superior to the g19,
but...when you look at parts cost and availability- mostly magazine cost, the Glock won out for me. I like to have multiple mags for a gun, and paying $40 + for a mag is more than I'm willing to pay.
 
#48 · (Edited)
I went through the same thing- deciding on the same 4 guns.
Walther PPQ is actually superior to the VP9;
I think the PPQ is superior to the g19,
but...when you look at parts cost and availability- mostly magazine cost, the Glock won out for me. I like to have multiple mags for a gun, and paying $40 + for a mag is more than I'm willing to pay.
Just a heads up, you can use the 18 rd mags from the Great- Canik TP 9 SA which are made by Mecgar and are only $24 for the PPQ
http://www.aimsurplus.com/product.a...+Series+9mm+Caliber+18rd+Magazines&groupid=16

To the OP Id go with the PPQ!
 
#17 ·
The Glock 19, hands down. It is a proven design. If you had a Glock 17, why do you not have it now!? To me it is one of the best striker fired designs and makes a great nightstand weapon. Get a Saf-T-Block trigger dongle thingee for it. I have them on my G17 and G36.
http://www.brownells.com/shooting-a...ocks/saf-t-blok-for-glock-reg--prod17097.aspx
I've always found the safety block thing kinda ironic.... A SAFTEY where you have to touch the trigger. A rather terrible idea IMO.

Buy a quality holster, chamber the pistol and put it in said holster.... Done.
 
#20 ·
I suggest you look at a CZ P-09 before you decide. It's what I keep on the night stand. It's a reliable performer and 19+1 of 9mil is a lot of firepower before a reload.

 
#32 ·
The Glock 19, hands down. It is a proven design. If you had a Glock 17, why do you not have it now!? To me it is one of the best striker fired designs and makes a great nightstand weapon. Get a Saf-T-Block trigger dongle thingee for it. I have them on my G17 and G36.
http://www.brownells.com/shooting-a...ocks/saf-t-blok-for-glock-reg--prod17097.aspx
Yea I regret selling the g17..but oh well.
My recommendation is to go to a real gun store, look at and handle the guns, and walk out with one.
That's exactly what I did and came home with the sig.
I don't get the fascination with ordering common guns from the internet, sight unseen.
Thought I would get a lot better deal but the gun shop was very competitive.
If you are ordering tonight but can't decide between several guns, you are ordering prematurely (immaturely).
Have been on this decision for 3 months now doing research.
Possibly he wants to order one before any possible election fears induced run on pistols or price increase due to sudden increase in demand.
yea that was a deciding factor also.

Got the sig p320 carry with 2 mags and a holster out of the box. Have read great reviews and just felt right in my hand.
 
#22 ·
Get the Glock 19. It is thinner, lighter, and mags are everywhere and cheap.
 
#23 ·
Since you have reservations with some of the others, though all terrific pistols, and you have experience with the Glock 17 then the Glock 19 makes a lot of sense for you.

I shot a P320C and loved shooting it but am not comfortable with the almost zero take up on the trigger. I have a Gen 2 Glock 19, a PPQ, and a VP9. Love them all.
 
#26 ·
Walther PPQ. World class ergonomics and reliability. The best trigger on any striker fired pistol in production. More accurate than any shooter will be able to accomplish. Get it!! No need to worry about a crisp 5.6lb trigger unless you aren't planning on keeping the finger out of the trigger guard until ready to fire.
 
#27 ·
Meh.. first off, why only striker??

And if you have a list that long... take your time.
 
#28 ·
Glock 21 shooting big,slow,quiet ashtrays that won't zip through the length of your house but knock a bad guy for a loop.
My PPQ's trigger got funky after about 300 rounds, got a "hitch" in it I couldn't stand and I sold it.
My awake housegun is a HK P30L with +p 124 gold dots. Bedside is a glock 21 or a glock24 with the big and slower sub sonic golddots.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top