Glock Talk

Glock Talk (http://glocktalk.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Glocking (http://glocktalk.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Glock 26 or 27 (http://glocktalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1456154)

45 Cal 12-04-2012 21:19

Glock 26 or 27
 
I've decided to sell my Springfield XDS and replace it either with a Glock 26 Gen 4 or Glock 27, Gen 4. While I'm sold on the platform (as I already own a G19 and love it), I'm having a hard time deciding which caliber to buy.

I plan to shoot and likely carry either gun in 9mm. Either buy the G26 or the G27 with a conversion barrel. I would typically go straight for the G26 due to it being a factory 9mm, but I like the idea of shooting the 9mm, .40 cal, or .357 SIG out of the same gun.

I guess my question is: How reliable is the G27 with a good conversion barrel? Is it reliable enough to trust your life to? And is it worth buying the 27 to have the ability to shoot 3 calibers?

Dreamliner787 12-04-2012 21:40

G27 is snappy and G26 are less snappy. I got the G27 with the Lone Wolf conversion and no issues so far with over 300 rounds through it and I would trust it just like I do my G19. I do have to say that with higher mag capacity, my preference has changed to carrying the G19 more but the smaller for of the G26/G27 still has it's place at certain times. I use the 9mm mags instead of the 40SW mags.

diamondd2 12-04-2012 21:53

G26. Shoot what you carry.

GPBob 12-04-2012 22:25

I posed approximately the same question earlier this year. I said I would go as far as changing out the ejector, extractor and spring loaded bearing in 9mm for the 27. I got more posts telling me to just go with a 26 and not trust my life on a conversion. Many said that it would be great for the range but just go OEM for defense.

I took that advice and dropped the 27 and now own two 26s. With a mixture of Corbon 115 +p and Speer Gold Dot 124 +p I believe I'm covered.

rilkil23 12-04-2012 22:34

As much as I like my G22 I have no plans to carry it with a conversion barrel. My G19c, and my G26 are my carry guns. I might pick up a 357 sig barrel someday for the range but I wouldn't be comfortable using something like that as my personal defense weapon.


Posted using Outdoor Hub Campfire

DocWills 12-05-2012 04:21

.....

AtlantaR6 12-05-2012 04:46

Why you no likey the XDs? I'm thinking of picking one up to replace my g26.

45 Cal 12-05-2012 05:40

I actually really like the XDS. The trigger is great, better than any XD I've fired, and I like the accuracy and size of the gun. There are just two things that are driving me nuts about it. 1) I hate that I've only got a 6 shot capability. 2) I absolutely cannot stand a safety on my carry gun and the XDS has the standard Springfield grip safety.

Bruce M 12-05-2012 06:09

Alot of people seem to have no reliablity issues with converson barrels. Alot of people also seem to have no reliability issues with platinum coated gadolinium guide rods. But apparently sometimes a few do. For carry put me in the column that much prefers a stock gun.

sioux565 12-05-2012 06:26

I say get the 27, but I am a little biased. I do agree with others about not carrying with the conversion kit in.

bac1023 12-05-2012 06:37

I much prefer 9mm.

HexHead 12-05-2012 06:43

Get the 26. I'd get a 39 long before I'd get a 27.

vmann 12-05-2012 07:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by DocWills (Post 19701957)
26, The 40 in a small package is a bit of a ticking time bomb. I would carry a 40 in 27 but I would not shoot it a lot. 9mm with good ammo will be fine. :supergrin:

re the bomb, nothing but the fact 40 is high pressure from the factory and stuff happens. especially in a short barrel locked breech with a loose chamber.:wow:

what a retarded post.....

ChicagoZman 12-05-2012 07:23

Have a 27 and carry it on occasion (typical carry gun is a 23). Nevertheless, I would recommend a 26 for the reason that it has slightly less recoil and will therefore be slightly easier to shoot rapidly in a self defense situation. I'm stuck in the 90s with my .40 self defense guns.

Were I to start over, I would get 9mm exclusively, but I'm too heavily invested in .40 (ammo, reloading components, magazines, etc.) to switch now.

LampShadeActual 12-05-2012 07:26

My experience around police agencies is that while a lot of M27's get bought, far fewer are kept by the officers, and even fewer are fired much. Marginally manageable, but not really fun to shoot.

On the other hand, a lot of M26's get bought, they are kept by the officers, and get practiced with. Manageable recoil and easy enough to shoot for practice. Carry what you practice with.

MNBud 12-05-2012 07:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by vmann (Post 19702231)
what a retarded post.....

I wasn't going to go as far as retarded but I agree with you.

tango44 12-05-2012 07:33

G26 of course!

LuckyG 12-05-2012 08:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by LampShadeActual (Post 19702267)
My experience around police agencies is that while a lot of M27's get bought, far fewer are kept by the officers, and even fewer are fired much. Marginally manageable, but not really fun to shoot.

On the other hand, a lot of M26's get bought, they are kept by the officers, and get practiced with. Manageable recoil and easy enough to shoot for practice. Carry what you practice with.

Yep. I personally like the .40 in my civilian SD guns, but I don't use sub-compacts. It is a fine caliber, generally, provided the shooter has good fundamentals and is willing to work with it. For the casual shooter (for lack of a better term), a good 9mm is probably a better choice.

Our LGC has a large NRA pistol program and we put a lot of students through basic and personal protection courses. Consequently, we see a lot of different handguns, calibers and skill levels. One year I was coaching a shooter (Basic Pistol) who was using a G27 with factory ball. After single shots we switched to two controlled shots. His second one went into the ceiling. Fortunately, our ceiling is armored with steel plates.

Students using 9mm guns are a lot easier to teach. You can concentrate on fundamentals and not get recoil mixed into the equation. For defensive purposes, mindset and hits are the important elements. A slight increase in terminal ballistics specs won't make up for lack of the other two. Even for experienced shooters, there is nothing wrong with a good 9mm, as long as attention is paid to proper load selection.

Chuck TX 12-05-2012 08:33

If you're going to carry it in 9mm, I'd get it stock in 9mm. Conversions are fun, lots of fun, but have not been reliable enough for me that I'd be comfortable carrying one.

sourdough44 12-05-2012 08:36

I vote 26.

HollywoodG23 12-05-2012 14:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by sourdough44 (Post 19702480)
I vote 26.


:agree: ....G26!!!!

Giggity-Giggity 12-05-2012 15:31

26!!!

Finestkind 12-05-2012 15:35

I love my Factory g27 and that is my carry gun when I do carry.


Finestkind

LT642 12-05-2012 16:32

I think you'd be better served shooting both if possible. The G27, isn't a range gun, it's a compact SD pistol. With that said, I own a G26 and have an issued G27. Every time we qualify, after shooting both, I always smile to myself and think how glad I am I bought the G26.
I shoot both equally well, no problems putting the rounds where I want them, but I much prefer the G26.

TheGlockTalker 12-05-2012 16:33

If you already own a 19 why not stay with the same caliber and get the 17 and 26?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 23:27.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright 2013, Glock Talk, All Rights Reserved.