Its a tough call but I would have to say I prefer the 228 to the P6, mostly because the trigger on the 228 is markedly better than my P6 and the 228 has night sights. Both feel great and my preference may change in the future as these two pistols are both fairly new to me. One thing is for sure, they are both very well made guns.

Do you prefer the P6 to your 228? I have a 228 and I can't justify getting a P6 (althought I want to). It is basically a single stack 228.